0 hotels match your filtersTry updating your filters or browse other hotels below.
Below are additional hotels in the area that do not match your exact search criteria.
See AvailabilityStrikethrough Rate:$99Discounted rate:$89USD/night
See AvailabilityStrikethrough Rate:$123Discounted rate:$111USD/night
See AvailabilityStrikethrough Rate:$99Discounted rate:$92USD/night- See AvailabilityStrikethrough Rate:
$140Discounted rate:$135USD/night 
See AvailabilityStrikethrough Rate:$139Discounted rate:$125USD/night
See AvailabilityStrikethrough Rate:$139Discounted rate:$125USD/night- See AvailabilityStrikethrough Rate:
$109Discounted rate:$102USD/night
Other Fire Island searches
All Hotels in Fire IslandHotel Deals in Fire IslandExtended Stay Hotels in Fire IslandPet Friendly Hotels in Fire IslandTop Rated Hotels in Fire Island
Good to know
Boutique hotels
7 hotels in Fire Island
Highest Price
$135
Lowest Price
$89
Avg. rating